Name Cause of Death Killer On-Screen Notes
Baby Samuel Sliced apart with knife Witch Yes
Fowler (Dog) Disemboweled Witch No Found dead
Caleb Unknown Witch Yes It is implied that the witch molested him
Flora (Goat) Killed and eaten Witch Yes
Jonas Unknown Witch No Debatable
William Gored Black Phillip (Goat) Yes
Katherane Sliced with billhook Thomasin Yes While attempting to choke her to death for the murder of her husband and children